You Admired the Woman Until You Had to Meet Her Mind

This There is something interesting about receiving criticism from a man who consistently admired your Instagram, admired your appearance, pursued you and expressed interest in having relations with you—only to eventually decide that the “unattractive” part is the way you think and speak.

Sometimes a man can admire the presentation of a woman while being completely unprepared for the depth of the woman he is looking at.

He likes the pictures. He likes the femininity. He likes the body, ambition and aesthetic. But when the conversation requires him to see higher than himself—to discuss race, community, education, accountability, family, culture and what we owe the generations coming behind us—suddenly the woman becomes “too much,” “negative” or, apparently, “traumatized.”

I refuse to confuse somebody’s discomfort with my lack of attractiveness.

At 31, “WYD?” Is Not a Personality

As a 31-year-old woman, it is a turnoff realizing how many grown men cannot articulate themselves beyond a “wyd?” aura.

What are we actually going to talk about?

Can you hold a real conversation? Can you disagree intelligently? Can you ask questions? Can you at least attempt to understand why somebody thinks differently from you before deciding something must psychologically be wrong with them?

Trying to insinuate that I am “traumatized” by my race is the easy way out.

Sometimes it sounds like somebody learned a word and ran with it.

Disagreement is not automatically trauma. Criticism is not automatically self-hatred. Discussing problems within the Black community does not mean somebody is ashamed of being Black.

Sometimes a woman simply has a developed opinion.

And if you disagree with it, bring something substantive enough to challenge it.

This particular man is approximately 29–30 years old, while I am 31. We are close enough in age that this cannot simply be dismissed as a generational difference. We are grown adults. At this stage, I pay attention to whether a man has developed the intellectual curiosity to discuss something beyond what everybody is doing Friday night.

My Standard for Men Started at Home

As a woman who has a real father and a real-life example of what a husband looks like through how my father treats my mother, men are held to a higher standard in my life.

My father’s military service also showed me discipline, responsibility, leadership and commitment. He did not serve this country carrying what I would describe as a coon-like mindset—where accountability toward our own community somehow becomes betrayal of Black people.

I grew up understanding that you can love Black people fiercely while still expecting better from Black people.

Sometimes that expectation exists because you love your community.

So when I encounter Black men who cannot distinguish criticism of particular behaviors from condemnation of an entire race, that intellectual limitation is unattractive to me.

You Can Celebrate Black Men and Still Challenge Black Men

I can celebrate educated Black men, present fathers, husbands, entrepreneurs, professionals and community leaders while simultaneously discussing behaviors from other Black men that have negatively affected Black women.

Those realities can coexist.

And as a Black woman whose artistry, businesses and writing can reach other Black women—and eventually younger Black and Afro-descendant girls—I take that responsibility seriously.

Visibility comes with responsibility.

I cannot encourage young girls to pursue education, recognize healthy relationships, understand their worth and expect respect while refusing to discuss behaviors they may encounter from men within their own communities.

That isn’t hatred.

That is advocacy.

Jacksonville Made This Conversation Personal

Some of my experiences with men from Jacksonville have made this conversation particularly personal.

I have encountered men whose inability to engage in deeper conversations has made me question what happened between their home raising and adulthood.

But this is bigger than whether somebody came from a traditional two-parent household.

Maybe you were raised by a single mother. Maybe a single father. Maybe grandparents raised you. Maybe you had an entire village.

Whatever your family structure, adulthood eventually requires you to ask:

What am I doing with what I was given—and what resources am I using to develop what I wasn’t given?

Your upbringing can explain parts of you without becoming the permanent ceiling over you.

At some point, you have to take responsibility for educating yourself beyond the environment that raised you.

Pick Up the Book Before the Paddle

That brings me to HBCUs.

Black men who have the privilege of entering HBCU spaces should take seriously what surrounds them.

An HBCU education should mean more than Homecoming, Greek life, parties, networking and being able to say you attended a Black institution.

There are libraries. There are professors. There is Black history. There are generations of scholarship, leadership, political thought, entrepreneurship and cultural development sitting directly in front of you.

Yet sometimes we are so quick to run outside and pick up a paddle before we pick up a book.

And that line is bigger than Greek life. It is about priorities.

A paddle can represent belonging. A degree can represent academic accomplishment. Neither automatically gives you intellectual curiosity, emotional maturity or community consciousness.

You still have to read.

You still have to listen.

You still have to learn how to articulate yourself.

You still have to become comfortable saying, “I don’t understand your perspective. Explain it to me.”

Education should expand your ability to engage with people who challenge you—not simply give you another credential while your worldview stays exactly where it started.

Walking Around With Your Eyes Open and Still Closed

And it’s just funny to me how some men who refuse to open their minds can walk around every single day with their eyes open and still be closed.

You can physically see the world without actually allowing yourself to experience its depth.

You can travel and still be closed-minded.

You can graduate and still refuse to learn.

You can be surrounded by successful people and never absorb the principles that made them successful.

You can attend an HBCU and never seriously engage with the history that made that institution necessary.

You can date Black women and never seriously attempt to understand what Black women experience.

And you can be surrounded by resources while remaining intellectually in the exact same place.

That is what I mean when I say open your mind.

It is not about agreeing with me.

It is about possessing enough curiosity to understand that your current perspective may not be the only perspective worth hearing.

When Surface-Level Socializing Becomes the Ceiling

There is another dynamic I have noticed, particularly when Black men move within social circles composed of other Black people and people of other races who may appreciate Black culture socially but do not necessarily engage with the deeper needs of Black communities.

Everybody can go out together. Everybody can eat together. Everybody can drink, party, travel, laugh, network and enjoy the same spaces.

But what happens when everybody leaves the room?

What are we building that does not require an audience?

What are we reading? What are we teaching? What are we investing in? What are we doing with education? What are we contributing to our communities when there is no party, brunch, function or Instagram story attached to it?

Sometimes the Black man becomes the mutual person in the middle of these different social environments. And from my experience, when a Black woman begins articulating concerns that go deeper than the surface-level conversations everybody is comfortable having, instead of engaging her intellectually, he may become defensive or insult her intelligence because she is taking the conversation somewhere he cannot—or simply does not want to—follow.

That is exactly where I disconnect.

Because at 31 years old, I cannot build compatibility with a man around the same cycle of going out, hanging out, eating, drinking and being social on the same shit without any regard for education, intellectual development, community involvement, ownership or being part of something operating on a more advanced wave of life.

There is nothing wrong with enjoying yourself. I enjoy life too.

But socializing cannot be the ceiling of your personality.

I need to know what happens when the music stops.

And Yes, I Consider This When Thinking About Husbands and Fathers

This conversation extends beyond dating for me.

In my view, men who cannot grasp the importance of listening, learning, communicating and considering perspectives beyond their own are missing qualities necessary to become the kind of husbands and fathers I respect.

Marriage requires communication. Fatherhood requires patience. Both require humility.

How are you going to guide a daughter whose experiences you refuse to understand?

How are you going to communicate with a wife when every difficult conversation becomes “you’re traumatized,” “you’re doing too much,” or “this is a turnoff”?

Being a husband and father is not simply occupying the position.

It requires the character, intellectual maturity and communication skills necessary to lead, listen, protect, learn and grow alongside your family.

That is exactly why my father’s example matters so much to me. I already know what commitment and responsibility can look like inside a household, so I am not interested in lowering that standard simply because somebody finds me physically attractive.

Maybe the Attraction Was Never Intellectual

That is ultimately what this interaction made me consider.

If you enjoyed watching me through Instagram, admired my appearance and wanted access to me physically, but suddenly became “turned off” when my articulation and opinions became impossible to ignore, perhaps the attraction never included my intellect.

Maybe you liked what you could see.

At 31, that isn’t enough for me.

I don’t need a man to agree with everything I say. Intelligent disagreement can produce some of the best conversations.

But bring something to the conversation.

Bring your experiences. Bring a book. Bring research. Bring history. Bring another interpretation. Ask me why I believe something. Challenge my reasoning and allow me to challenge yours.

Just don’t substitute psychological labels for intellectual engagement.

Because the older I become, the less impressed I am by a man simply being attracted to me.

Can you communicate with me? Can you teach me something? Can you learn something? Can you think beyond yourself? Can we disagree without disrespecting one another’s intelligence?

Those questions tell me far more about a man than a “wyd?” aura.

Conclusion: Thank God I Listened to My Discernment

Perhaps that is what makes this entire interaction more revealing than upsetting.

This was a man who admired me, watched my Instagram, found me attractive and expressed interest in becoming physical with me. Yet the deeper the conversation became, the clearer it became that attraction and compatibility are two entirely different things.

And thank God we never had sexual relations.

My discernment was ringing, baby.

Sometimes discernment isn’t some dramatic revelation that somebody is horrible. Sometimes it is simply that internal realization:

I can’t get down with this man.

Not because he has to think exactly like me. Not because I believe I am intellectually superior to everybody who disagrees with me.

But because at 31, I need more than attraction and a “wyd?” aura.

I need a man capable of asking why. A man capable of reading. A man capable of listening. A man capable of disagreeing without reaching for a psychological label because he cannot articulate a stronger response.

I need somebody who understands that being educated is bigger than possessing a degree, being cultured is bigger than knowing where everybody is going this weekend, and having substance requires more than a “wyd?” aura.

Life can include the restaurant, the vacation, the drinks, the music and the function. But there should also be conversations about education, family, business, ownership, community, history, spirituality, financial development and what we are actually building with the lives we have been given.

And when I think about husbands and fathers, those qualities matter even more.

So maybe the greatest takeaway from this conversation is simple:

You can admire the woman from Instagram and still not possess the depth required to walk beside the woman when she puts the phone down.

Some people walk through life every day with their eyes wide open and their minds completely closed.

Thank God my discernment allowed me to see that before intimacy ever complicated the lesson.

Discover more from AYEDNICOLE

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading